Crooky ([info]crookykanks) wrote,
  • Mood: cynical

Spoiler Alert! HBP - Read at own risk!

How crazy were those last few chapters anyway!?!?!?! I felt, not really surprised that old Albus kicked the bucket, but what stunned me (as a growing Snape fan) was the WAY that the old man died! How cruel and unrelenting was that?!?!?!? And Lupin/Tonks being canon? That I REFUSE to believe! Who has kidnapped JK Rowling and attempted to take her place for the last eight or so chapters of HBP? More importantly, whose briliant idea was it to write in those completely weird bits, like the partial werewolf bite on Bill and the vampire at Slughorn's Christmas party? And seriously, "Galatea Merrythought"? Did somebody run out of last names?

I'll admit, I liked the book in most respects (especially the Horcruxes and Luna's commentating) and I found some of the romance well done. But "Cissy" being a canon nickname for Narcissa Malfoy? Draco being assigned to murder Dumbledore? and the entire cave chapter just didn't make much sense. Inferi? Did that come from Scooby-Doo on Zombie island? I expected slightly more feasible plot twists. Though through all this, somehow, I feel neither cheated nor dissatisfied!

Excuse this pointless post as a way for me to rant and rage without being banned from a community or giving away plot spoilers to those who do not yet have a copy of the book!

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 5 comments

[info]fakeconcerns

July 17 2005, 00:20:21 UTC 6 years ago

I HATE SNAPE!!! haspdhtpqsehtpasehtsht That really ticked me off when he did that. What a bastard. Uggggghhh. And, yes, I just finished the book. =) I'm also kind of upset that Harry gave up on Ginny that quickly. Dang it, if she wanted to hang in there why didn't he just let her? There goes the good ship... (I'll bet it's not over, but that's just me being overly-hopeful. Hey, I can dream...) What's all this about the school closing? I think not. And I did find the inferi things a little bit sketchy.. but it's magic. I didn't see the reference to Lily's eyes at all. Maybe I was half asleep while i was reading that part (more likely than not)... Call me! I need to talk to someone about this, and Sarah hasn't finished the book yet...!!!!!

[info]crookykanks

July 17 2005, 01:48:22 UTC 6 years ago

I honestly haven't decided where to place Snape yet, and I don't think I'm going to for a long time. This needs serious deliberation and perhaps a bit of rereading and fact chcking before I can decide where I think his loyalties lie, if he has any....

[info]girl_in_a_well

July 18 2005, 13:42:29 UTC 6 years ago

The Last 8 Chapters

I totally agree. Enough said. Snape wha? I never thought he would have killed old Dumbledore, but everyone has their price I guess. And what was with all the happiness? I know it's nice but it just wouldn't happen. Harry and Ginny(basically), Ron and Hermione(it's so gonna happen), Fleur and Bill, Lupin and Tonks(wtf?)and technically Mr and Mrs Weasley. When Hagrid came into the room at the end I was just waiting for him to after Minerva to marry him. Geez Louise...Meh...I want Sirius back.

[info]crookykanks

July 18 2005, 14:59:25 UTC 6 years ago

Re: The Last 8 Chapters

I agree completely! But the weird thing is, I went back and listened to said chapters on the book tapes read by Jim Dale, and they sound a lot more plausible there for some odd reason.... I guess it's all just starting to sink in.

[info]lostmymindagain

July 18 2005, 18:43:19 UTC 6 years ago

Re: The Last 8 Chapters

I finished it!! I can't believe Snape would murder Dumbledore. Just hearing Dumbledore pleading with him made me very upset. All in all, HBP was well worth the wait, minus the minor annoying bits. But more on that later. XD
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…